Finding the perfect pair of jeans can be as challenging as trying to navigate an unfamiliar city without a GPS. But there’s just something about a vintage pair of jeans that has us running towards our closets with excitement. The hunt for that elusive pair of perfectly faded and high-waisted jeans can be quite the task. Fear not, dear reader! Erie has a plethora of options for vintage denim shopping. Let’s dive right into our top picks!

1. Calamari’s Squid Row - With a name like that, how can you resist? They specialize in vintage fashion with a heavy focus on denim. The prices vary, but on average, you can find a fantastic pair of denim for around $40.
2. Secondhand Rose - Take a stroll down 26th Street to get yourself to Secondhand Rose. They have an ever-changing inventory of vintage jeans that are sure to make your heart skip a beat. You might even find a hidden gem for as low as $25.
3. Carousel Consignments - This gem located in the heart of the city has a fantastic selection of vintage denim at an affordable price. Prices range from $25-$50, and let’s be honest, you can’t put a price on a great pair of vintage jeans.
4. Molly Brannigans - Not only does this pub have fantastic beer, but they also have a fantastic consignment shop attached to it. They have a large selection of vintage denim with prices ranging from $30-$50. Grab a drink while you shop, and you’ll be sure to walk out feeling like a fashion icon.
5. Captain Billy’s Superstore - Ahoy! Captain Billy’s is a unique store that carries everything from vintage decor to clothing. If it’s denim you’re looking for, you won’t be disappointed. Prices start at $20, and they have a great selection of sizes.
6. City Thrift - While you may need to do a bit of digging, City Thrift has been known to have hidden gems in their racks. You just might find your new favorite pair of vintage jeans for a steal at around $20.
7. Plato’s Closet - More of a chain thrift store, Plato’s Closet isn’t necessarily exclusive to vintage denim, but they have a great selection nonetheless. They often carry on-trend styles of denim that are no longer sold in stores but still in fantastic condition. Prices can range anywhere from $20-$50.
8. The Thrifty Nickel - For the country lovers, the Thrifty Nickel is the store for you. They have a wide selection of vintage denim jackets, overalls, and of course, jeans. Prices vary, but you’re sure to walk out with a timeless piece for around $40.
9. STEAMERIE - Located in the heart of downtown Erie, STEAMERIE is your one-stop-shop for all things vintage. They have a great selection of denim, and bonus points for the store’s overall ambiance. Prices start at $40.
10. Once Upon a Child - Don’t let the name fool you. While they specialize in children’s clothing, they also have a dedicated section for women’s clothing, including denim. They have a consistent selection with prices ranging from $10-$40.

There you have it, folks! Ten fantastic options for scoring a timeless piece of vintage denim in Erie. Remember, the hunt is half the fun. So grab a friend, a coffee, and start your denim adventure today!